Christian critics on Apocalypto
Friday, December 8th, 2006Mel Gibson’s Apocalypto is out, and Christian critics are weighing in. It might not be the sort of film that usually appeals to evangelical movie-goers, but between Gibson’s anti-semitic remarks earlier this year and the Passion of the Christ phenomenon, a lot of Christians are curious about his latest film.
At Past the Popcorn, Jenn Wright is less than impressed with Apocalypto. While praising the film’s success in avoiding the sorts of stereotypes often employed when ancient cultures are portrayed, she laments that Gibson tainted the film with “wildly out-of-place and terrifically inappropriate comic relief.”
Phil Boatwright at Preview isn’t thrilled with the movie either. In his view, the extreme violence and over-the-top brutality drowns out whatever moral core might lie at the heart of the story. Unlike The Passion of the Christ, Apocalypto’s violence lacks a moral core to justify its excess.
Darrel Manson at Hollywood Jesus largely concurs. While acknowledging that violence can sometime add an important element to a film, as in Saving Private Ryan or Hotel Rwanda, the violence in Apocalypto is simply beyond what is required for the story. From his review:
The film becomes more about the carnage than the story. When violence takes precedence, a film is badly off track. And even though this story may need violence, viewers are assaulted with more cruelty than this film’s theme or artistic level merit.
If do you decide to see Apocalypto, at least you’ve been warned! It sounds like it’s certainly not for the squeamish.

The Alliance is a community of hundreds of Christian organizations–including small, one-person ministries, large publishers, and everything in between–all united by their desire to do online ministry. The Alliance provides both technical and strategic help for Christians trying to make their online ministry as effective as possible. The Alliance also gathers each year at the 
